Thursday, June 12, 2008


A Florida lawyer was suspended today for three years for intentionally submitting false information in an adoption case. She should have been disbarred period.

Here is the story. Here is the link.

Tallahassee lawyer suspended in adoption case

Published Thursday, June 12, 2008 at 3:14 p.m.
Last updated Thursday, June 12, 2008 at 3:14 p.m.

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — A lawyer who knowingly submitted false information in an adoption case was suspended for three years Thursday by the Florida Supreme Court, although two dissenting justices said she should have been disbarred.

The majority justices in the 5-2 ruling acknowledged Joyce Sibson Dove's ethics violations ordinarily would deserve disbarment, but they cited mitigating factors.

Those included the Tallahassee lawyer's lack of a prior disciplinary record, community service such as helping Ukrainian hospitals and orphanages bring sick children to the United States for treatment, and her remorse and rehabilitation since the 2002 violations.

In dissent, Chief Justice R. Fred Lewis wrote that it was among the most flagrant cases of lawyer misconduct the high court has ever reviewed because it affected vulnerable children and families.

"I suggest that the imposition of only a suspension under these egregious circumstances undermines professionalism, creates fertile ground for public distrust, and constructs unjustifiably lenient precedent that we will regret in the future," Lewis write.

Justice Barbara Pariente, while also dissenting, noted the three-year suspension is the most serious penalty Dove could get short of being disbarred.

Dove did not immediately return a telephone message left at her office.

She had gone ahead with a termination of parental rights and adoption to an out-of-state couple although she knew the child's maternal grandparents by law had priority. She hid those facts from the court and the adoptive parents, and she lied in court documents.

The case later was settled with the birth mother and grandparents getting visitation rights.


Researcher said...

She stole a child's family and gets a suspension? That's it? She should be in jail. The suspension will do nothing but postpone her doing the same thing again. Until real action is taken against attornies and agencies defrauding families and the courts, nothing will change or stop people like Dove from doing the same thing again and again and again. This is not a case of inexperience but a case of unethical, heartless money grubbing.

Amyadoptee said...

Mr. Thomlincon, sunny, or whatever your name is,

Please cease and desist from my blog. You are a very creepy person. Every link that you are putting on my blog I am sending to blogger and the other folks who are innocently involved in whatever you are doing.

Your ip address is You are out of Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh, India. You are using Vidash Sanchar Nigam Ltd. internet service. You are using MSIE 7.0 on a Windows XP system. You have hit my blog 5 times on July 31,2008, 12 times on August 1, 2008, 4 times on August 2, 2008, 7 times on August 4, 2008 and one time so far today. Your comments are no longer wanted. It is always on this post. If you continue, I will humiliate you on blog land. I have left a comment on one of your blogs. I will report to blogger as a spam blog. Keep it up mother fucker. I will nail your ass to the wall. Go fuck with someone else. Your time on my blog is done.